Why People Use Ice
It’s simple. Ice chills a drink quickly. On a hot day, or when you’re out dancing and sweating, nothing beats that instant cold hit. For ciders, beers, or even lagers, it can make a drink more sessionable, easier to sip without that first sharp kick of alcohol, and just more refreshing overall.
There’s also the aesthetic. Seeing a glass filled with ice makes a drink look cooler, more appealing, and feels like you’re treating yourself, even if it’s a cheap cider. It’s part of that bar culture vibe.
The Downside
Ice doesn’t just cool your drink. It dilutes it. Slowly, the flavour fades, the carbonation drops, and what started as crisp and fruity can end up thin and watery. For craft beers, lagers, or proper ciders, this can kill the tasting experience entirely. Subtleties of malt, hops, or apple notes get lost under a layer of melted water.
Even in ciders, where you might think the sweetness will carry through, ice can mask the apple aroma and soften the natural tang. That refreshing bite you expect in a cider like Magners can end up much weaker.
Ice in Lagers?
I’ve talked to people who put ice in their lager, and it always makes me raise an eyebrow. A cold lager straight from the fridge is crisp enough; add ice and you’re left with a flat, diluted version. Sure, it might be more “refreshing” on a scorching day, but it’s not the same drink anymore.
The lager loses its balance between bitterness and malt. The fizz disappears, and what’s left is… just cold water with a hint of beer. For serious beer fans, this is sacrilege.
When Ice Works
Ice isn’t always the enemy. For cheap, fizzy ciders or lagers where the flavour is simple, or when the priority is sheer refreshment over taste, it works. It’s about context. A crisp Magners on a sunny day over ice can be enjoyable, as long as you’re aware that the full flavour is compromised.
For cocktails or mixed drinks, ice is obviously essential ... it dilutes, chills, and balances stronger spirits. The issue arises when people apply the same logic to beers or ciders designed to be drunk neat.
Pro Tips for Ice in Cider and Beer
-
Use fewer cubes: One or two is enough to chill without diluting too fast.
-
Go bigger: Large ice cubes melt slower than small ones.
-
Pre-chill your glass: If you chill the glass first, you might not even need ice.
-
Know your drink: Cheap, fizzy ciders handle ice better than craft options.
-
Serve and sip fast: The longer the drink sits, the more watered down it gets.
My Take
For me, ice in cider will always be nostalgic. It reminds me of nights out, cheap drinks, and trying to survive a packed club without overheating. But if I want the real deal, proper taste, proper fizz,
I stick to it straight. Same goes for lager. The ice might make it “easier,” but it also takes away what makes the beer enjoyable in the first place.
Wrapping Up
Ice in drinks is a habit as old as pubs and clubs. It cools fast, it refreshes, but it comes at a cost. If you’re chasing flavour and complexity, skip the cubes. If you just want something icy-cold to sip under the sun, a little meltwater won’t hurt. Just know what you’re giving up in return.
Comments
Post a Comment